Monday, January 5, 2015

The amusing 'problem' of education.

I've just been reading Dave Cormier's post 'Trying to solve the problem of education in 2015' 

There was much too much in it to respond with a short comment.

Indeed, I shall no doubt have to go back and reread it a number of times...

So here is an initial rambling response for me to reread...

I am fairly convinced that there is not, and there has never been 'a problem' of education.  Dave does suggest that is 'a complex problem' here. I agree.

Education...a mish mash

Education and therefore problems (depending on one's view point as to what constitutes education or problems) is a multiple, diverse and complex mish-mash (nexus) of often conflicting discourses.

'Education is a set of social systems developed to encourage learning at scale.' 

Education, viewed from one perspective, is about elites establishing and maintaining social, cultural and economic hegemony, from another perspective it is a business opportunity, a market for selling technology, seen  from another perspective it might be viewed as a question of architecture, seen from another perspective it might be viewed as a leisure activity...one might go on.

It strikes me that simplifying 'education' to a question of 'learners' 'learning' masks more than it reveals.

The problem(s) of education(s) in the 19th Century (England)

From a historical perspective, the growth of compulsory education reflected a changing economic landscape and a growing middle class.

So we are not talking about any old learning - we are talking about learning for operating in a specific environment.

General education emphasised teaching or instruction, of distribution of knowledge.

Physical education and team sport emphasised the importance of moulding a fighting force.

Moral education emphasised a religious agenda.

We would need to differentiate how education was conducted for different classes, different regions.

In the 1850's the children of Manchester cotton spinners would have had little real use for learning the classics, its central place on the syllabus expressed more about aspirations to become part of a culturally recognisable elite.

"'Upper middle-classness' came to be more a matter of educational standards and social manners than of family connections...The comradeship of the 'old-school' tie." (Weinberg, 1967)

A quote from 1904 illustrates this:

"The actual education of the boy, the development of his brain power, of his mental faculties, is the last thing the parent has in mind. The training of the boy's character is what he is looking to."

Sporting prowess was for many years seen as much more important in many elite schools than nerdy academic studies. Education here was about learning to be a 'gentleman'.

Basic general education was of use to all in an industrialising economy:

the ability to read, the ability to count, the ability to follow instructions or give instructions.

I would imagine that the most important of all of these would be 'following instructions'.

Rote learning, or memorisation enabled the individual not just to mug up facts, and equations but enabled him to become one of a body of men.

What constitutes learning has been diversified according to the needs of elites.

The education offered in a British elite public school (private school) would bear little ressemblance to what was offered in a school for training kids to be a mechanic.

If we consider Dave's definition of learning 'that mysterious thing that all living things seems to do in adapting to their environment,' education therefore would be more about creating an environment in which kids were to adapt.

We learn to operate in a social environment.

For anyone wanting to teach everybody a foreign language, like Dave's Johann wanting to teach all the Swiss to read, it is very difficult to implant new languages or practices which seem alien to the 'learners.'

Indeed, learning which was social/economically inappropriate may have been/be/would be of little use to the individual however engaged the learner might be...

I ask myself the question of 'knowledge' and the colonisation of folk 'knowledge' by an academic elite...

If an Amazonian tribe have the means to cure certain illnesses with plants, the value of this 'knowledge' requires a sponsor to exploit it in an academic journal, which of course the Amazonian tribe does not have. The same goes for folk tales or music exploited by 'composers' (remixers) and 'authors' who were able to distribute 'their' works to a wealthy audience.

The Film Educating Rita illustrates (amongst other things) the conflict experienced by the individual who finds themselves not in their place.


Elite education or general education in the nineteenth century might be contrasted with non-conformist, cooperative or Quaker movements which encouraged learning and reflection as part of their mission.

Evening classes for the workers, were alternative means for individuals to learn skills which might enable them to progress upwardly socially. With industrialisation came a more diverse range of possibilities.

Education viewed from this perspective was less about teaching and more about learning. Here were upwardly mobile competing groups for new opportunities.


The 'problem(s) of education in 2015'

When I hear 'it is generally accepted that we need to be raising a generation of life-long learners', I fear that what we may be saying is that we need to have a generation who will have to accept geographic mobility, instability, constant retraining, for ever diminishing returns.

If globalisation and a digital economy in 'developed countries' entails more outsourcing of production, centralisation of control, massive concentration of capital, reduction of public services, reduction of value of professions, then what will be the value of 'life-long' learning?

One major advantage for some of 'life-long learning' might be 'life-long testing'...

If we are talking about the most economical way of testing - then surely we are talking about standardised testing?

'Caring about learning' can be seen as caring because I love doing something or caring because I need to do something to make a living.

People are more likely to care about 'learning' or anything else if it enables them to achieve what for them are primary objectives (generally, initially at least, financial).

A major challenge for reforming educators is to show that education is no longer simply about preparing people to be fit for jobs or social classes but is also about creating new activities and new sources of wealth or well-being.

Or maybe we need to see it more  from a non-conformist, Illichesque learning web perspective?

Dave asks how do we 'teach learning'?

Well I have the impression that we are beginning to see small steps in that direction.  I hear now of courses in 'creativity', in multiple digital literacies...

I am not sure that I go along with the 'inevitability' of bureaucratisation of 'new means of enabling learning', of education?..

It seems to me again, that we are in the realms here, of non-conformist, reading groups outside of existing elites which grow up from the base...(still problems of finance...?)

I have a feeling that the rhizome is model for competing knowledge creation communities.

I suspect that it might enable us to better understand the complexity of the mish-mash of discourses which are underpinning apparently fixed systems.

I am far from sure that you can or that should attempt to 'roll out rhizomatic education' anymore than you can or should attempt to roll out non-conformism...

I am fairly sure that rolling out 'uncertainty of knowing' rather than 'knowledge' is a hard sell...(unless you can show positive after-effects).

I am fairly convinced that the rhizomatic learning that I experienced with 'rhizo14' revealed the same powerful discourses which underpin higher education: research agendas, academic discourses, senior life-long learners...so there were intertwining and competing communities...

I think 'rhizomatic learning' is NOT how I think of education, it might be a model for the complexity of society, it might be a model of knowledge development.

One might replace 'school' with 'internet' and remix Illich:

the internet 'is the advertising agency which makes you believe that you need the society as it is.'

If this is the case, is the society we are being sold one in which life-long learning is rather like life-long pornography or life-long football, about amusing ourselves to death (Postman)?

Is the problem today of education, spending our time asking ourselves what the problem of education is?

Are we learning to ask ever more unanswerable, unGoogleable questions, while trapped into seeing simple exploitation as complex?

Are we forever publicly challenging intellectually a system but never actually doing anything to change it?

Ultimately with the complexity of the systems in which we are entangled, perhaps the only sensible response possible is to stop caring...(too much)?













26 comments:

  1. Find most reliable service which consists of professional essay writer in UK.The essay writers will ensure that all of your academic dreams come true and that you achieve the highest success.Our essay writers can produce impressive essays each time. Their expertise in the matter reflects in the superior quality of their service.We never miss deadline for any of the essay.Online Essay help service has a reputation of delivering the work within the stipulated time

    ReplyDelete
  2. In such situations, taking assignment help online from experts ends up to be very helpful. The experts provide you with professionally written assignments which are individually crafted to cater your needs and meet your expectations. Java Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  3. I've really like your blog and inspire me in many ways. If you need any assistance regarding web designing assignment help, then you are at right place. Its high time to beat your competitors and score high grades in our guidance. We will provide you supreme quality papers at cheapest price.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dissertation helper are providing their service in very economical prices on students assignment help platform.They have very deep knowledge about dissertation writing.so take advantage of their services in very nominal charges.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is where you might have started your search for assignment help. The previous consumers give their feedback on the website to let the other users know about the quality of their service. For example, if you go to the AllAssignmenthelp.co.uk Reviews, you can get to know the opinion of different users about their services. You can also check other websites to compare and select the best service for you.

    ReplyDelete
  6. All the details are in this post is very interesting and brilliant and I am glad to see this post. Your blog is amazing dude. i love to visit it everyday. very nice layout and conten Benefits Of The Interpersonal Skill

    ReplyDelete
  7. Students can now make their life easy and hassle-free by opting college homework service of tophomeworkhelper. It is one stop gateway for success in the academic field. You can ask for college homework help online. We will make it for you at affordable price

    ReplyDelete
  8. Write assignment Samples with expert writers. Contact us today to avail up to 20% Discount. Ordering for the first time? It’s your lucky day, apple decision making offers up to 30% off on your first order. Our experts are working on all over the world and still now they solve 1000+ assignments.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Essay Help will ensure that all of your academic dreams come true and that you achieve the highest success.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Use composing administrations under Assignment Helper to upgrade your scholastic execution. These administrations are accessible with 24*7 client backing to give moment backing to all understudies. Presently, the time has come to visit the site and statement your request.
    Dissertation Writing Service
    Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is something very important to understand, I really appreciate your efforts to share such information. Here I am also sharing some information that might be useful for students looking for Assignment Help , in various subjects like, MATLAB Assignment Help , or Matlab Assignment Help Online.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Many students have expressed their disappointment with other tools that they had used previously. Therefore, our developers have designed a tool that will deliver 100% accurate results. Your professors will not be able to detect even 1% plagiarism in your document. Also, the paraphrasing tool online will keep the meaning of your texts intact.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you for this wonderful information looking forward for more. If you are in need for online assignment writing assistance for an intricate assignment and thesis topic, then avail our assignment writing service in Australia. and save your time to relax and do your studies properly. Our Assignment Help Australia online service in Australia has earned huge popularity among both domestic and international students. There’s no better place in the Australia than firstassignmenthelp . Contact us now to buy assignments online in the Australia Leave your tensions to us and enjoy your free time.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks for your post. I have read through some similar topics but your post has given me a very special impression about problems in education. Students must have to look on UK Dissertation Proposal Writing Services to solve their study problems.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I have been looking for such great information for some time thanks I finally found it. From sweetbreads to sandwich bread, to gluten-free bread, people are using these handy bread maker machines to replace the less than appetizing store-bought bread. But choosing a bread machine isn’t exactly easy. Visit Best Buy Bread Maker for more.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Mobile Game Development

    Thank you for organising such positive technologies. Keep It up. Customers can now make their life easy and hassle-free by opting mobile game development help service of Sysbunny portal. You can ask for mobile game development. We will make it for you at affordable price.

    ReplyDelete
  17. They all work towards making sure that the applicants are not discriminated by colour, gender and background. content writing services

    ReplyDelete
  18. Máy tính để bàn là một trong những thiết bị điện tử khá thông dụng được nhiều người sử dụng để học tập, làm việc và giải trí. Mặc dù chúng ta sử dụng máy rất cẩn thận nhưng có những thói quen tưởng chừng như vô hại lại ảnh hưởng đến tuổi thọ của máy tính để bàn cũ của bạn. Vậy, cụ thể những thói quen đó là gì? Nếu bạn cũng đang sử dụng máy tính để bàn cũ, hãy tham khảo thông tin ở bài viết dưới đây để có thông tin cho mình nhé:
    Xem thêm:Những thói quen xấu ảnh hưởng đến tuổi thọ của máy tính để bàn cũ

    ReplyDelete
  19. Mobile Application Development Company

    Wow, Very effective tips. Thanks for sharing this wonderful and helpful material.
    This is such a great resource that you are providing. I love seeing this blog resource.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I’m very glad to have such an informative post. Certainly, this compelling post will encourage readers to choose Affordable Conveyancing services. You can contact us@ Affordable Conveyancing

    ReplyDelete